Should You Cut Off a Toxic Family Member? A Therapist’s Perspective

by | Psychotherapy in Ontario

Family shapes so much of who we are—our beliefs, our emotional patterns, and even our sense of self. But what happens when the family you grow up in is dysfunctional? Many people struggle with relationships that feel draining, painful, or even harmful, yet they are told that family bonds should be unbreakable.

Therapy offers a space to untangle the past, understand how dysfunction has shaped you, and decide what kind of relationships you truly want moving forward. For some, healing means learning to set boundaries while maintaining family ties. For others, it means making the difficult choice to step away. No matter the path, therapy can help you process the impact of your family dynamics and build a healthier, more authentic life.

The Impact of Growing Up in a Dysfunctional Family

A dysfunctional family is one where emotional needs aren’t consistently met, whether due to neglect, toxic dynamics, or patterns of control, criticism, or enmeshment. Some common experiences include:

  • Growing up with emotionally immature or unavailable caregivers
  • Feeling like you had to be the caretaker for a parent or sibling
  • Living in an environment where conflict, secrecy, or instability was the norm
  • Struggling with low self-worth, trust issues, or difficulty regulating emotions as an adult

Dysfunction in families isn’t always dramatic or overt. Sometimes, it’s the subtle, repeated invalidation of emotions that leads to wounds just as deep as more obvious forms of harm.

How Therapy Supports Healing

The wounds of a dysfunctional family don’t simply disappear with time. Many people carry them into adulthood, affecting relationships, self-esteem, and even mental health. Therapy helps by:

  • Validating your experiences so you can stop second-guessing your emotions.
  • Exploring how your past impacts your present, including your patterns in relationships.
  • Developing emotional intelligence and learning how to express your needs.
  • Practicing boundary-setting, whether that means redefining your relationships or stepping away entirely.

One of the hardest aspects of healing is realizing that not every family relationship can—or should—be salvaged. This leads to an important question: what happens when a family connection is actively harmful?

Should You Cut Off a Toxic Family Member?

The idea of cutting ties with family can feel overwhelming. Many cultures and societal norms teach us that family is sacred, no matter the harm they cause. But sometimes, staying in certain relationships does more damage than walking away.

Choosing to distance yourself from a toxic family member isn’t about punishment—it’s about self-preservation. If a relationship is constantly draining, manipulative, or emotionally unsafe, it’s okay to question whether it belongs in your life.

Signs that a relationship may be too toxic to maintain:

  • You feel emotionally exhausted after every interaction.
  • Your boundaries are constantly ignored or disrespected.
  • The relationship triggers unresolved trauma, anxiety, or guilt.
  • You find yourself justifying their harmful behavior instead of addressing it.

Stepping away from a family member—whether temporarily or permanently—is deeply personal. Some people take space to heal and later reconnect on healthier terms. Others realize that the healthiest choice is to let go entirely. Therapy can help you navigate this decision without guilt or self-doubt.

Blood Isn’t Always Thicker Than Water: Rethinking Family & Community

There’s a saying: Blood is thicker than water. But the original phrase is actually:

“The blood of the covenant is thicker than the water of the womb.”

This flips the meaning completely. It suggests that the relationships we choose—our friendships, partnerships, and chosen family—can be stronger than those we were born into.

Many people feel pressure to maintain toxic family connections because of tradition, culture, or guilt. But the truth is, family isn’t defined by DNA—it’s defined by emotional safety, mutual respect, and genuine connection.

In a world where many people are more disconnected than ever, it’s important to build supportive, loving relationships beyond family ties. Whether that’s through close friends, mentors, community groups, or even therapy itself, healing often comes from finding people who truly see and support you.

Finding Support at WellSite

If you’ve struggled with family dysfunction, toxic relationships, or feelings of isolation, you don’t have to navigate it alone. Therapy provides a space to explore your past, process your emotions, and create a life built on relationships that truly support your well-being.

At WellSite, our therapists help clients break free from unhealthy cycles and build a sense of connection that feels safe, supportive, and fulfilling. Whether you want to repair family bonds, set new boundaries, or redefine what family means to you, we’re here to support your journey.

Reach out to us today and start building the relationships you truly deserve.

Jennie Koops

Jennie Koops

I hold a Master’s in Psycho-Spiritual Care from Emmanuel College at the University of Toronto and have extensive experience working with individuals facing addiction, trauma, anxiety, depression, and family or intimate partner violence. My approach is trauma-informed and client-led, integrating therapeutic modalities such as Emotion-Focused Individual Therapy, Narrative Therapy, Internal Family Systems (IFS), Dialectical Behaviour Therapy (DBT), and Values-Based Integration Process. Together, we’ll work to uncover your inner strengths, heal emotional wounds, and help you thrive in all aspects of your life.